Father’s Day Minus My Father

Father’s Day was never a big deal for my Dad.  It was not his thing.  He didn’t expect gifts or meals or cards, even.  I seem to remember a good Father’s Day for him was one where all of his four kids called him.  That made him happy.

Last Father’s Day was spent raising funds for Donna’s Good Things at the dance recital for the studio where we support scholarships.  My Dad helped me out with a few of those over the years.  He liked to sit behind the table and talk about his granddaughter who had died from a brain tumor and that he missed so terribly.  He would tell every stranger he met that her name was Donna and that it wasn’t right for him to be alive and her to be dead.

This first Father’s Day without my Dad is one I’ve been trying to not think about.  It’s easy to keep busy and distracted when you are mothering two young ones.  But today as I sat down to do a little photo project as a gift for my husband tomorrow, I keep coming back to photos of my own Dad.  I miss him.

As I type those words, “I miss him,” I take a deep breath and stare out the window.  I live in a neighborhood where a lot of Orthodox Jews live.  It is Saturday morning, so Jewish families are coming and going, walking past my window.  Every family has a father, all of whom seem actively engaged with their kiddos as they stroll past.  This serves both to make me miss my father more, but to also feel grateful for the Dad I had.

Our relationship wasn’t perfect, my childhood wasn’t perfect, and my Dad certainly wasn’t perfect, but he was there.  Always.  There is something to be said for being there, showing up, staying close.

Me and my Dad, c. 1979.
Me and my Dad, c. 1979.

I got to spend 45 years with my Dad, which is a hell of a lot more time than so many other folks get with their fathers.  I am grateful for that.  So very grateful.

One of the things I miss most about my dear Da developed in recent years.  It was our mutual grief that provided an extra layer of texture to our relationship.  We shared a sadness that was just understood, the common denominator between us.  We talked about our grief unselfconsciously.  I think for both of us, it was a major part of our day-to-day lives without defining our day-to-day.  We both had learned how to make room for the sadness without it crushing us.  That connection we had, now that it is missing, makes my own grief feel a bit more crushing these days.

And again, I pause my typing to look out the window.  And breathe.

Tomorrow is Father’s Day.  I will do what I can to make my husband feel extra appreciated and valued.  He is a rock star in the world of fathers.  My own Dad would often remark, never in front of my husband, but aside to me, what a good father my husband was.  I think he saw the level of involvement and engagement that my husband has with his children, my Dad’s grandchildren, and was amazed.  “You got yourself a real good one there,” he would tell me often.  Truth.

But in the midst of my two boys and my husband, somewhere in between breakfast in bed and dinner out at a favorite Mediterranean restaurant, in between a walk to the park or planning for next week’s road trip, I will be thinking of my Dad.  He is never far from me, never leaves my thoughts for too long.  I will be sad and pine to hold the hand of the man that brought me into this world.

Instead, I will take another deep breath, hold the hands of my boys and my husband and remember to be grateful for the Dad I had.

He was a good one and I miss him.

The Things We Keep

Yesterday I went to my Dad’s condo.  I don’t go there often, actually avoiding it as much as I can.  It makes me sad to be there.  When a person dies, aside from love and memories, what remains is their stuff.  Junk now, to most anybody but the deceased.  I don’t say that as a disparagement to my dear Da, but as truth.  The weight of it, how I feel when I am around the remnants of my Dad’s life, is a heavy burden to bear.

When my Mom died ten years ago, I was buffered from the responsibility of taking care of her things, as it was my Dad’s call.  Now, there is no one left to call it.  It will go.  The four kids will pick through what remains of his life and find for ourselves what holds meaning.  There are books and my Mom’s oil paintings, some of his treasures from travels to Ireland, photographs.

What we keep close to us in our day-to-day lives says something about us, I think.  Our things are revealing.  One of the things that has always made me wistful when visiting my Dad was seeing what he kept of my Mom’s.

He has been a bachelor for the last ten years of his life, and if he ever dated or enjoyed another romance, he kept it to himself. Because of that, he lived a bachelor’s lifestyle.  Frozen food.  Not a lot of creature comforts.  A spare home life that didn’t involve hosting others.

He was surrounded by a lot of paper in his last years.  Piles of papers and a hodgepodge of his interests that hung on the walls — photographs of buses and trains (his life’s work was in transportation), union posters rallying the middle class, calendars marking his days.

There, in the middle of all that bachelor random chaos, was my family’s china cabinet I remember so well from childhood.  The dining table was now used as a desk, but a few feet away was the companion china cabinet.

The cabinet was devoid of papers.  It’s glass was kept clean, making it easier to see the treasures inside.  There, among the piles of ten years of widowhood, the china cabinet stood tall, uncluttered, reminding my Dad, I imagine, of a life he once lived with my Mom when the papers were confined to his desk or garage.  A better life, maybe.  A more comfortable life, certainly.

I miss my folks terribly.  Never more than when I stand in my Dad’s empty condo surrounded by what remains of their lives together, my Dad’s life alone.  46 years of marriage, 10 years of widowhood, and all that remains are boxes of papers and a china cabinet full of Waterford crystal, ornate knick knacks, hand painted plates with delicate flowers and birds, and porcelain vases.

That china cabinet was my Dad’s last day-to-day connection to my Mom. It held the pieces of their lives together that grounded him somehow and was, I believe, his uncluttered homage to their marriage.

My Mom and Dad in a favorite photo taken by me sometime in the early 2000s in Alabama.  They spent their winters in Gulf Shores, Alabama leaving the cold Illinois winters behind.
My Mom and Dad in a favorite photo taken by me sometime in the early 2000s in Alabama. They spent their winters in Gulf Shores, Alabama leaving the cold Illinois winters behind.

Don’t Worry About a Thing

It will be okay.  I know this because if you wait long enough, the sting of initial grief passes, eases, ebbs.  I’ve buried my Mom and daughter, so burying my Dad is not the shock it could have been had this been my first time at the sadness rodeo.  But it still sucks.

Today really sucked.

In a veil of light rain, I drove to my childhood hometown to finish some of the busywork of death — pick up my Dad’s death certificates at the funeral home and arrange for his headstone at the cemetery.

I haven’t lived in the south suburbs since 1992, moving from my parent’s home, my childhood home, to Chicago’s north side as a young woman of 22.  That was over half my life ago.  The area is simultaneously foreign and familiar.  It feels odd to be back there, odd to bury my Dad there, like I’m leaving him without a ride home.

He moved to the South Loop neighborhood after my Mom died ten years ago.  Like me, he, too, grew away from his south side roots, transplants both of us.  Out of the blue he bought a condo last spring a bit further north.  In typical Dad fashion, his decision was not up for discussion.  It was his decision to make and he was not one to listen to the concerns of his children.

The view was spectacular — skyscrapers and CTA tracks.  I got why he liked it so much. I wish he had had more time there.  He did, too.  When I looked for a new home for him in February, I thought he might like that the two windows in his assisted living unit overlooked a grassy area with a lot of trees.  He hated it, preferring his urban landscape to anything nature offered.

You do the best you can when your choices are limited.  I tried and my Dad tried.  We both did the best we could in the face of his changing health.  “Don’t worry about a thing, nothing will turn out all right,” was one of my Dad’s longstanding mantras. Wiser and more cynical words have never been spoken.

His point was that spending any amount of time or energy worrying was a waste of both of those precious resources.  He always said that his mother taught him not to worry, that worrying never changed anything, so why engage in it?  It seemed so simple when he said it.

When he was diagnosed with lung cancer last year, I knew he was worried.  He didn’t talk about it too much and he preferred to keep the diagnosis private.  Need to know basis, you know?  I felt his relief after going through the radiation treatment.  His radiation oncologist was the same doctor who treated my Mom and daughter.  Talk about freakishly small worlds — oncology, even in a big city like Chicago, can be fairly incestuous.

He let me go to one of his appointments with her last year.  Just one.  My Dad was very independent in most every way.  After his treatment ended, Dr. Marymount said to my Dad, “I think we got it.  Lung cancer is the least of your worries.”  She sent him on his way with an order for follow-up scans in three months.  His cancer was caught early, stage 1.  None of us were really worried.  Turns out, we should have been.

Death Certificate

Lung cancer is what is listed on his death certificate under “cause of death.”  Lung cancer.  Of course.  Freaking cancer.  Of course.

My Dad never made it to a follow-up appointment or scans.  He was too busy with other medical crises that on the surface had absolutely no connection to lungs or cancer.  I remember in January pushing, gently, for repeat scans.  My Dad was already hospitalized.  It seemed like a task that should be easy to accomplish.  Ha — in Hospitalville, “common sense is non-sense,” another one of my Dad’s favorite mantras. Perhaps I should have pushed more assertively.  Perhaps it wouldn’t have made a bit of difference.

We’re all gonna die someday.  April 29, 2015 was my Dad’s day to die.  Lung cancer is what got him in the end.  My personal belief is that he died before May 1 to spare his estate the cost of another six grand of assisted living expenses and another six hundred dollar insurance premium.  He knew.  I am convinced of that.  He knew.

I miss him.  His death has brought me back to my Mom’s death ten years ago. They are together again now, side by side, just like in the full sized bed they shared since their 1958 marriage.

Graves

I miss them both.  It feels a bit like a Mack truck ran over me today, so I don’t even know why I’m sitting up at 8:45 at night typing these words, other than I need to. Writing is part of the way I move through grief.  Which takes me back to the first sentence of this post, “It will be okay.”  It will.  It’s not okay right now.  Right now not much of anything feels okay.  But it will be okay again.  I hope.