The Santa Question: When Your Kid Stops Believing

Cue the carols and the jingle bells and the egg nog — all the folks are getting their Christmas on this time of year, including four year old Mary Tyler Son. Except, little logical thinker that he is, he’s been asking a lot of questions about Santa. Hard questions that lead me to believe he will lose his belief in Mr. Kris Kringle a hell of a whole lot sooner than I thought he would.

What on earth is a Mom to do?

Seriously — what do you do when your kid, at four, is outgrowing the magic, or as some (but not me) would say, myth, of Santa? Kids need magic. Adults need kids to need magic, cause, let’s be honest, we live vicariously through them for that kind of thing.  I was a little shocked and heartbroken to hear his questions repeated over a few days this week.

  • Where are Santa’s elves, reindeer, and sled when he is visiting with all the kids?
  • How does he make reindeer fly?
  • Why does he say HO HO HO?
  • Is he (the guy at the mall he takes his pictures with) just a person dressed up like Santa?
  • How can he see me when I am all the way at my house?

For better or worse, Mary Tyler Son is a bright, inquisitive child.  He wants to know how, what, why, when, and where and doesn’t take “because I said so” as an appropriate answer to his questions.  And, as a rule, we love to entertain his questions, to see how his mind works and is processing everything the world throws at him, including Santa Claus.

You see, I think my boy wants to believe in Santa, it’s just that the evidence doesn’t really stack up and he’s too literal and logical a thinker to ignore that evidence.  Are you real, or just a man in a suit?

I posed my concern on Facebook the other day and got more than a few comments encouraging me to respond with the dictum, “You have to believe to receive.”  No offense, but what works in your house might not work in mine.  For my husband and I, that answer doesn’t match our style of parenting.  More power to you if it meets your needs, but I was still struggling.

This morning a friend reached out and asked if I wanted to go visit Santa together with our kiddos.  Why yes, yes I did.  I had been encouraging Mary Tyler Son to keep track of his questions so that he could ask Santa himself. Way to pass the buck, amirite?  I thought maybe the Big Guy himself could solve the problem.

Lo and behold, he did not disappoint.

Mary Tyler Son has visited with the same Santa for three years now.  This man is a gem and is the real deal (Northbrook Court, yo, for all you locals). Thick beard, shiny white hair, big belly and an accent that is hard to place. British?  Actor? More than anything, sort of an oratorical voice, but familiar, warm, comforting.  I kid you not that every year I have wanted to crawl into his ample lap and pour out the sob story of my life.

Santa makes everything better.

My boy timidly approached him.  There was no one else waiting to visit or have photos snapped, so Santa was very generous with his time.  I’m not joking when I say that he spent 10-15 minutes talking with my boy, explaining things like astrophysics and how they apply to reindeer flight.  The circumference of the earth was mentioned a time or two.  Mary Tyler Son posed his first question:  How do reindeer fly?

Sure enough, Santa had an answer.  Mrs. Claus feeds the reindeer magic corn one night a year — Christmas Eve.  The rest of the time, he said, they are just regular mammals, eating regular food, and walking around their pens on the North Pole.  Next question!

Where are your elves and sled and reindeer?  Well, at the North Pole, of course!  Someone has to build the toys.  Santa explained that Mrs. Clause keeps an eye on things and keeps everything running smoothly while he is away meeting children.  Next question!

How do you get all the toys to all the children?  This is where the astrophysics came in.  Santa very creatively and patiently explained the speed with which reindeer who have ingested magic corn can fly.  Mary Tyler Son was mesmerized.  He was eating it up, just as those reindeer ate the corn.  Honestly, I lost track of all the details and numbers that were flying around, but not my boy.  He was in seventh heaven.  Next question!

A star will always adorn Mary Tyler Son's face in these posts, as he is my light, my star above, that brought me out of the darkness after his sister's death.
A star will always adorn Mary Tyler Son’s face in these posts, as he is my light, my star above, that brought me out of the darkness after his sister’s death.

This is when things got serious.  My boy, brave as he is, asked the question that might have held the answer he didn’t really want to hear.  You see, I think my boy wants to believe in Santa, it’s just that the evidence doesn’t really stack up and he’s too literal and logical a thinker to ignore that evidence.  Are you real, or just a man in a suit?  I held my breath, and was grateful I wasn’t alone to field the question.

Santa bent down close to my son and looked him straight in the eye, “I’m not real.  I am what you call immortal.  Do you know what immortality is?  It’s when you live forever and real people don’t live forever, do they?  I am not a real person, I am a spirit, an immortal spirit, a miracle of wonder.”  Well, there I was blubbering away, because of course we know, more than most, that real people die and there Mary Tyler Son was, nodding and agreeing.  He, too, knows that real people die, and there was Santa, confirming his belief, he was not real — he was better.  He was a spirit, a wonder, a miracle, immortal.

Good God.  All this wisdom from a mall Santa Claus.  Forget it.  I am a believer.  In that moment, right there, I became a believer.  Because somehow, some way, that beautiful man knew exactly, I mean exactly what to say to my son that would enable him to maintain his belief.  Hell, that would enable me to find my belief, lost long ago.

Thank you, mall Santa, thank you.  You reminded me of the importance of hope and belief in not only our kid’s lives, but in our own.  And hell, if I didn’t believe, would this have been possible:

The anchor is an ancient sailor's symbol of hope.  Mary Tyler Baby will always proudly wear the anchor in my posts, as he is my own little anchor, proof of what can happen when you hope.
The anchor is an ancient sailor’s symbol of hope. Mary Tyler Baby will always proudly wear the anchor in my posts, as he is my own little anchor, proof of what can happen when you hope.

Post script:  When you’re a mom blogger, you learn that there is just about anything that can cause controversy.  Last year, naive gal that I am, I learned that there was a whole anti-Santa platform of parenting.  No disrespect intended, but there is a school of parenting that tells you if you encourage your child to believe in Santa, you are dealing in lies that will harm your child.  I was honestly a bit shocked, but to each their own, you know?  I vacinnate, I circumscise, and yes, I want my children to believe in Santa.  To each their own, indeed.  Merry Christmas to all! 

LOUD AND PROUD, BABY!
LOUD AND PROUD, BABY!

If you like what you read here, might I recommend the following:

Cancer Mom v. Mom

A Walk in the Woods:  Finding the Teachable Moment

Acorns in Cancerville

Hosting the Holidays

I have been lucky enough to spend the vast majority of my holidays with the very same group of family for all of my forty-four years.  For my entire childhood, my Mom hosted Christmas and my Aunt hosted Thanksgiving.  It was set in stone and, as far as I know, not really a discussion.  We all just knew where we would be on those most symbolic of holidays.

These were lovely traditional gatherings.  Both dinner tables featured turkeys, and I’m not just referring to the errant odd relative, cranberry sauce, and margarine, not butter.  They were predictable and warm and so very anticipated.  When I was a kid, I loved, loved, loved those gatherings — even more so than the presents under the tree.

I never thought too much about the work attached to hosting a family event, but I do remember how stressful it was for my Mom.  My folks’ marriage, I think — cause honestly, who really knows — was quite a bit different than my own marriage.  My husband, unlike my Dad, does the holiday cooking.  Trust me when I say that if I were ever to host a Thanksgiving dinner independently, it would be turkey tacos on the menu.  I stick to what I do best — cleaning our home, setting a beautiful table, making certain people not only eat good food, but eat it in a warm and special setting.

I could never cook a turkey people would want to eat, but then again, Mary Tyler Dad would never think to spray the table with mini gourds or arrange a vase of flowers.  Yin and yang, style and substance.  It works for us.
I could never cook a turkey people would want to eat, but then again, Mary Tyler Dad would never think to spray the table with mini gourds or arrange a vase of flowers. Yin and yang, style and substance. It works for us.

After my Mom was diagnosed with a brain tumor and died less than a year later, well, the holidays were in a bit of a flux on our end.  My folks never again lived in the home they shared after my Mom got sick.  That home was their retirement home and located three hours outside Chicago.  They rented an apartment in the city to be closer to better medical care and family.  Small apartments with old widowers are not really accommodating to large family gatherings.

Just a couple of years after my Mom died, my daughter was diagnosed with her own brain tumor.

Ho ho ho.

For my husband and I, the holidays will never be the same.

But for most folks sitting around our holiday table, things are as they were before my Mom or daughter died.  Busy, hectic, loving, joyful, blessed.  That is what I want for my sons.  I want them to grow up with what I had and still value — a warm extended family that actually enjoys one another’s company.  We don’t all share the same politics or enjoy the same movies or books or music, but there is honest to goodness love and history there.  Shared love and shared history.

So that is why, just a year after our daughter died, Mary Tyler Dad and I made the choice to move into hosting the holidays.  We knew our limitations, so we opted for Thanksgiving over Christmas.  Taking the tree and presents out of the equation put the focus on food and family.  We could handle that.  With pleasure.

The devil is in the details.  Turkey shaped butter.  Butter tastes better when it's shaped like a turkey!
The devil is in the details. Turkey shaped butter. Butter tastes better when it’s shaped like a turkey!

This was our third Thanksgiving that we’ve hosted since making that choice. There are a new generation of cousins running around and causing mischief. They are all five and under.  Donna, who would have been the elder statesman of this generation of cousins, is only with us in her framed image that looks down over the table.  But Donna always loved a party, so that is what we try to create.

As an adult now, and a grieving adult at that, I so feel the stress that my Mom must have felt each and every Christmas in her own hosting duties.  My Dad was always there on the holidays, but he is from a different generation.  He carved the turkey, sure, but he didn’t cook it or stuff it or purchase it.  Just like he paid for the Christmas gifts, but didn’t choose or wrap them.  Different division of labor.  I get it.

I laugh now (it’s easy a week after my hosting responsibilities have ended) as the holiday season approaches and I can feel my stress level rise.  I always feel closer to my Mom during these days and say a silent “thank you” for everything she did to give us so many beautiful and warm holidays.  A few weeks ago I read a blog post chastising people from stressing over making a holiday dinner.  Pffft.  Honestly?  If I am hosting 25 people for a sit down dinner, I am allowed to stress.  You know why?  Because it’s stressful.  End of story.

Even with my husband “man”ning the kitchen, there are still a hell of a lot of things to accomplish to make a warm and comfortable gathering for two dozen folks.  There is cleaning and linens and table setting and flowers and shopping and stowing of random bric a brac that always manages to be most present this time of year.  There are closets to clear for extra coats and a kids table to figure out.  There are outfits to coordinate for two brothers.   There is furniture to move to accommodate all these folks in a dining room made for half their numbers.

The kid table.  I actually wanted to eat here myself.
The kid table. I actually wanted to eat here myself.

It’s work, yo.

But, hallelajuh, what joyful work it is, even if I do curse in the moment.  And, damn it if I am not lucky to have this kind of work.

One of the things I put in place when we started hosting was a gratitude toast.  Ha!  All my relatives make fun of me and a few even roll their eyes.  I don’t care.  Those eye rolls are all in fun and what’s the sense of gathering on Thanksgiving if we can’t, for a few short moments, tell one another, the people we love most in this world, about our blessings?  One of my finest moments this Thanksgiving was my cousin who revealed in his toast that he thought about it ahead of time.  Three cheers for gratitude!

In my own toast, I always like to say the names of the people we are missing.  I don’t know why, but like most families, my own doesn’t talk enough about those we love who have died.  I don’t understand it myself, cause if we don’t talk about them who will?  Say the names, people.  Say the names.  Jack and Carolyn and Donna and Donna.  See?  It’s not so hard.  Say the names of those you love who have passed before.

But this year, generating snickers and hoots all around, I also expressed gratitude for having people to cook and clean for.  This was not a martyr’s wail — woe is me who had to brush ground in graham cracker crumbs out of the living room rug before guests arrived.  NO.  This was a grateful woman’s words of wonder that I am that lucky human being who has a room full of people in my home whom I get to cook and clean for, who willingly come to our home to celebrate a sacred day of gratitude.

Everything is better with chocolate -- even the holidays.
Everything is better with chocolate — even the holidays.

How amazing is that?  How lucky am I?

My Mom taught me well, she did.  And, like my Mom, I, too, will always and forever stress over hosting the holidays.  But never for a moment misinterpret that stress as a lack of gratitude or a complaint.  No way.  Despite my hardships, I am one hell of a lucky lady.  I get to spend my holidays with people I love, and whom, I think, love me.

Happy hosting holidays, folks.  If you are hosting, remember these words as you plan that menu and iron those linens and wonder where that 12th spoon has gone off to.  What a lucky freaking person you are.

Happy holidays, from me to you.

Dude, you should spend your holidays with me. You should subscribe.  Here’s how:

Type your email address in the box and click the “create subscription” button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.

JFK’s Death Through the Eyes of an Irish Catholic Born After He Died

When President John F. Kennedy was killed, 50 years ago today, I was not even a glint in my parents’ eyes.  They were sleep deprived after having delivered their second child, my sister, just two weeks earlier.  I was still six years away.  So why on earth is this day so significant to me?

I can sum it up pretty easily for you — my family is Irish Catholic and we come from the South Side of Chicago.  The Kennedys are our royals, the First Family of Irish and Catholics and corruption.  Our local version of the Kennedys are the Daleys, and well, suffice it to say that my first son’s middle name is Daley.  These Irish Catholic political dynasties, now a dying breed, were something I grew up with and was always profoundly proud to be a part of, even on the periphery.

So, yes, today I have Kennedy on my mind.  I have spent hours Googling images of that fateful day fifty years ago and listening to the most amazing memories on NPR.  Leave it to the BBC to have the best coverage this afternoon.  It included first person interviews with Secret Service agent Clint Hill, who is the man who climbed on the trunk of the Presidential motorcade as Jackie was climbing out of the back seat.  It included 93 year old retired Dallas police officer Jim Leavelle who arrested Lee Harvey Oswald and was handcuffed to him when he died.  It included a young wife and mother who watched from the curb as her President’s brains splashed across the street.  It included one of the ER docs at Parkland Hospital who worked tirelessly to bring President Kennedy back, despite every medical indication being that he was gone.

That day fifty years ago changed the course of American history and global politics.  And for whatever reason, Irish Catholicism aside, I have always been attracted to the fairy tale of Camelot.  Hell, I have a Pinterest board dedicated to this era.  Something about the fashion, the optimism after World War II, the glamour and tragedy of the Kennedys.  It’s just rich — all of it so very rich and potent and interesting and magnetic and hopeful for me.  It’s probably no coincidence that my folks got married in 1958 and my Mom always and forever reminded me of Jackie Kennedy herself.  My folks bought into the whole Kennedy mystique, too.

Ich bin ein Kennedy, know what I mean?

The Kennedy Monument in Ft. Worth, Texas -- significantly more moving than any public monument in Dallas.
The Kennedy Monument in Ft. Worth, Texas — significantly more moving than any public monument in Dallas.

So imagine my surprise and excitement when we went to adopt our new baby boy in Dallas/Ft. Worth.  Touching down at the DFW Airport, I couldn’t help but notice all the banners calling out jfk.org — the cyber home of the Sixth Floor Museum at Dealey Plaza where President Kennedy met his fate those fifty years ago.  I hadn’t made the Dallas/Ft. Worth – Kennedy connection until I saw those banners.  And this from someone who has made a pilgrimage to Chappaquiddick of all places.  I was excited and disappointed in myself all at the same time.

As we sped away to meet the mother of our soon to be son, I made a silent vow to go to the museum before I left Texas, come hell or high water.  And, being a gal of my word, I did.

Let me tell you, that is one hell of a museum.  I am the type of person who prefers a museum to a mall (I mean the best museums have the best gift shops anyway, amirite?), and a city to a beach.  I stole away for a few hours one day, leaving my family in Ft. Worth, as I made the trek to the Sixth Floor Museum, Dealey Plaza, and the infamous Book Depository building.

The Book Depository Building, now knows as the Sixth Floor Museum
The Book Depository Building, now known as the Sixth Floor Museum

I was in the Irish-Catholic-political-dynasty-Kennedy-ZONE.  I was grateful to be alone, as I don’t think I know another person who would match my enthusiasm for this jaunt.  After getting over my disappointment that cameras were not allowed in the museum itself, I simply gave in to the experience.  It is a world class museum, curated with great care.  The Kennedy presidency is covered as is the zeitgeist of the era.

And then, as you move through the exhibit, you come to the day itself, November 22, 1963.  President Kennedy’s last night was spent in a hotel in Ft. Worth.  It was rainy during his outdoor early morning speech in Ft. Worth that Jackie opted out of. Did you know that the couple was mourning the death of their two day old infant just three months earlier?  But the campaign never stops, does it?  Not when you’re President.

Within a couple of hours the clouds and rain had lifted and the sun shone brightly.  The couple flew into Dallas and requested the open top car to diminish any obstacle between them and the people along the parade route as they snaked through the city streets.  Always campaigning.

The museum exhibit deftly tells the story of that bright Friday day in Dallas.  How there were full page ads in the local newspaper taunting President Kennedy.  How the police commissioner went on local radio programs requesting the citizens of Dallas be polite and welcoming of him.  How a man named Zapruder filmed the motorcade, inserting himself in one of America’s saddest days on record.  How bullets were fired and a President died.

Standing where Zapruder stood and feeling sad and moved.
Standing where Zapruder stood and feeling sad and moved.

I cried.  It was really well done.  I will never forget it.

So much was lost fifty years ago today, forever changing the trajectory of America.  As I’ve said before about grief, it both hardens and softens you.  The same can be said of collective grief — that day in America, we both hardened and softened. America felt deeply, moaned in unison, wept openly, feared for itself.

So, yes, I was not born during Kennedy’s lifetime, but I grieve as if I were.  I wonder about an America where three assassinations in five years wholly altered the course of history.  I cry for kids who lost their father, a culture who lost their icon, a religion that lost its pioneer, a mom who lost her son, a First Lady who lost her husband, a country who lost its shining hopeful light.

The grassy knoll.
The grassy knoll.

Rest in peace, President Kennedy.  Thank you for what you have taught me. I am grateful to you.

If you liked my post and would like to read other ChicagoNow bloggers reflections on Kennedy’s death, check out these blogs: