Princess Kate Giving Birth, Body Image, and Other Disasters in Celebrity Culture

I pretty much stayed out of the fray with the birth of the most recent royal.  I’m not a royalist or an Anglophile and after the death of Diana, well, my sole icon obsession is relegated to Irish Catholic political dynasties.  Can you say Kennedy or Daley?  I can, and often do.

That said, my heart kind of melted when I saw the photos popping up on my Facebook feed.  The sheer joy and utter amazement on Price William’s face as he held his newborn son.  Well, yeah, that got to me. ‘Well done,’ I thought, and wished him the best.  I mean, seriously, how could you not feel a little tug?  There is such joy and potential in a newborn.  And there was Diana’s first grandchild all perfect and untouched.

Then I saw it.  Within hours of the happiest of couples leaving the Lindo Wing with their newly swaddled bundle of joy, who also just happens to be the future Kind of England (how’s that for silver spoon?), a blog post headline remarking on Princess Kate “still” having a pregnant looking belly hit my screen.

Princess Kate Leaving Hospital

For criminy’s sake, people.

While I know this post was not meant as condemnation or intended as a slam (which is why I am not linking to it), the title alone feeds into the heinous expectations women place on themselves due to our obsession with celebrity culture and the messages the media regularly and loudly send us. And let’s not kid ourselves, ladies, as there is certainly a male contingent who hold women to these expectations as well.  Have any of you seen the husbands in the Real Housewives franchise? These dudes exist and sometimes live right next door to us.  Shivers.

A friend remarked on the same thing in a Facebook status update this morning.  Why are we needing to defend the extra few inches around Princess Kate’s middle just HOURS after she gave birth?  Here this gal just did one of the most miraculous things a body will ever do, and the chatter starts, even if it is meant to be humorous and “tongue in cheek,” as another friend suggested.

I promise you I am not humorless, but I also promise you that when we start to refer to women as “still” having a pregnant looking stomach 24 hours after giving birth, even in humor, we are treading into some pretty icky and tricky waters.  These messages stick to us as women, consciously and subconsciously and unconsciously, just as much as the peanut butter from our toddler’s fingers.  Whether we want to or not, we are receiving the message that perfection is what is demanded.  Always and in all ways.

Giving birth is not enough.   No, mam.  We need to give birth, then walk out of the hospital in our skinny jeans.  And if we don’t?  Well, what the hell is wrong with you?  Are you lazy?  Genetically doomed?  Not up to Hollywood standards?  The answers are simple:  NO, NO, and YES.  Cause most of us are not Hollywood starlets, and that’s okay.

We have the capacity to reject these messages, but only if we are aware of them.  Know what you are looking at, take the smallest of steps back and see the messages, both written and unwritten.  Step away from the US Magazine trash and Perez Hilton bash and know that they are powerful.  Very powerful. But you are powerful, too.

And if you’ve just given birth and have more of a triple layer chocolate cake top rather than a muffin top?  Well done, mama, well done.  You are amazing.

But don’t just believe me, a publicly established feminist blogger.  Take it from my new BFF Ralph, who left this message on the Facebook thread I referred to above:

I think women can be almost as hard on themselves as the media. As a man, I want to state out loud that a little shape is a wonderful thing  no matter the shape. Most of my male friends would say the same. The ones that don’t aren’t worth bothering with usually, anyway. But you guys probably know this by now.

Do you?  Do you know this by now?  I think many of us don’t, on a very real and potentially damaging level.  I speak from experience, cause I am the first to condemn myself for the extra weight I carry.  Sigh.  But I’ve done this since the 8th grade when at probably no more than 100 pounds, I was embarrassed to walk around the local pool without a towel around my middle. I just shake my head now.

Do your thing, Princess Kate.  Mother that baby, wear your polka dot dress with the elastic waist that highlights the abdomen that just birthed the future Kind of England.  Work it, girl.  Don’t listen to the chatter.  And for the rest of us?  Know that you are better than okay.  Know that you have the capacity to decipher messages, overt and covert, that try to tell us otherwise.  You work it, too.

You like this?  You want more of this?  Then hit me up for a subscription.  Here’s how:

Type your email address in the box and click the “create subscription” button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.

This Woman Is Not Allowed to Cry

This is a photo, a mug shot to be precise, of Helen Ford.  I don’t know much about Helen Ford and the first I heard of her was yesterday.  Helen was arrested and charged for the murder of her eight year old granddaughter.

Helen Ford, charged and arrested for the murder of her eight year old granddaughter, Gizzell Ford.
Helen Ford, charged and arrested for the murder of her eight year old granddaughter, Gizzell Ford.  Photo courtesy of the Chicago Police Department.

The little girl’s name was Gizzell.  Remember that name, because chances are, she does not have an adult in her life that will work to tell her story and honor her the way I do my own dead daughter.  Rest in peace, Gizzell.

The details about the incident are horrifying.  I read about it in a Chicago Tribune article written by Rosemary Regina Sobol and Geoff Ziezulewicz. They write:

The prosecutor said Gizzell had injuries old and new over her entire body: Cuts, bruises and scratches to her face, ears and lips, bruises and puncture wounds on her back, chest and abdomen and bruises on her arms and legs.

Her neck showed signs of hemorrhaging and fractures and broken cartilage, Pillsbury said. The girl also suffered deep lacerations to her buttocks and had ligature marks on her ankles and wrists, as well as circular burns on her body that may have been cigarette burns, Pillsbury said.

When they examined the home for evidence, police took a pole, twine and cables, some of them smeared with blood. In the bedroom where the girl was found, investigators found blood splattered near her body, Pillsbury said.

Investigators also determined that Gizzell had suffered trauma to her head long enough ago that maggots had hatched in the cuts and spread to the front of her scalp while she was still alive.

Reading that description made me weep.  Maybe it had the same effect on you, too.  The details, specific and grotesque as they are, are important to recognize, though, as a means to bear witness to Gizzell’s suffering. Imagine an eight year old girl, defenseless, in her family home, abused and murdered at the hands of her own grandmother.

I live in a big city, so stories of child abuse are not unfamiliar to me.  They can be seen regularly peppering the headlines and newscasts.  In the moment they are wrenching, and then you watch a commercial, or click to a gossip column, the sad tales of abused children forgotten.  After my daughter was diagnosed with cancer, though, and after four miscarriages, I value the life of a child, any child, more deeply, more profoundly.  I am ashamed to admit that.  The stories, the headlines, the names seem to stick with me now in a way they never did before.

When I see a story of extreme child abuse and neglect, I tend to click on it, steeling myself for what is certain to turn my stomach.  And sure enough, my stomach is always turned.  My eyes tend to well up in response to a child who is missing the must fundamental things a child requires from the adults in their life — love and protection.  I think about my own daughter, who was surrounded by boat loads of love and protection, and yet those were not enough to save her from cancer.

Child abuse is preventable.  Every time, every situation, every whip and slap and burn and cut and chain and restraint is preventable. The prevention gets mucked up in bureaucracy, to be sure, but the presence of bureaucrats is no excuse for the suffering of an abused child.  If anything, it only adds to the manner in which that child was failed.

Seeing this mug shot makes me angry.  You are not allowed to cry, Grandma.  What are her tears about, I wonder.  Is Helen Ford sad she went one step too far this time?  Is Helen Ford sad she was caught?  Is Helen Ford wondering how she ended up in front of a police camera?  Is Helen Ford resentful that she was straddled with the care and feeding of the eight year old daughter of her bedridden son?  Is Helen Ford weeping for herself and what has become of her life?

I don’t know.  And truth is, I don’t care.  Wipe your tears, Grandma.

Gizzell Ford

Rest in peace, Gizzell Ford.  May you know peace, for what surely must be the first time, in death, if not in life.

Click here for more information about child abuse and how to detect and prevent it.  

Want more of my point of view?  If so, here is how:

Type your email address in the box and click the “create subscription” button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.

Coming Out of the Closet II: Donna’s Things

Closets are very personal spaces.  Even anonymous ones, like hotel closets — cool and spare, empty as they are, offer glimpses of passing guests after adding their clothes and shoes.  We know something about the person behind those clothes and shoes just by looking at them.

Donna’s closet is the same.  As I look through the bins and hangers and boxes, Donna’s things spilling out, those things lead me to memories.  So many memories.  Wonderful memories, bittersweet memories.  They are visceral reminders of the person who was, but no longer is.  Our Donna.

The closet.  Donna on the left, Mary Tyler Son on the right.  Hats and blankets and baby things interspersed.
The closet. Donna on the left, Mary Tyler Son on the right. Hats and blankets and baby things interspersed.

Donna didn’t love the typical pink and purple choices offered for girls. She loved black and navy right along with her pink.  And she was particular.  And delicate.  I could buy her a white cotton broadcloth blouse and not worry for a moment about stains.  That is a rare quality, indeed, in a two, three, and four year old.

These are a few of her favorite things.  Stacked in big bins, never to be worn again.
These are a few of her favorite things. Stacked in big bins, ready to be worn.

In the bins above, I remember the sweaters, some hand knit, that she wore so well.  There is the pink ombre skirt she rocked with black Cons and a tank top.  There is the blue floral blouse that she wore to pre-school and ran around the front yard chasing bubbles in, laughing all the way.  There are the striped leggings that always reminded me of the witch from the Wizard of Oz. She was bald when she wore those.  And so very tiny.

On top is the baby blanket our dear family friend knit her.  The blanket came with a hat to match.  We didn’t know if Donna would be a boy or girl, so the colors are sweet and pastel.  We wrapped Donna in that on the way home from the hospital.  Her little two day old self refused, absolutely and loudly, to wear the matching hat.  Pffft.  She was smarter than us even then.  Who needs a hat in the middle of July?

Hair bows and floral fleece.  I love that the bows look like they are in prison.  Donna hated hair bows.  The only one she would wear was a black crochet spider.  She was never a princess, more like a tough little cookie.
Hair bows and floral fleece.   No boys allowed.

Donna hated hair bows.  Hated them.  When you are a Cancer Mom, the hair on your child’s head is a big deal.  A very big deal.  Donna lost her hair three times.  She had beautiful curls to start, just like her brother.  Beautiful curls.

In the midst of treatment, I always imagined a long haired Donna sitting on my lap hearing stories about how she was so sick as a young child.  That was never to be.  When Donna’s hair would grow back, it was not the same.  It was straight and the texture was much stiffer than her original hair.  We have science to thank for that.  Her treatment was strong enough to permanently change the texture of hair that grew on her head.

The one hair decoration Donna would consent to was a black crochet spider. She was so her own little being.

Hats, hats, and more hats.  Three bins of hats, many handmade and given with love.  A kid with cancer needs hats for warmth and sun protection.  Donna had a whole wardrobe in every color and for every season.
Hats, hats, and more hats. Three bins of hats, many handmade and given with love.

Thank goodness Donna loved hats.  Hats are crucial to a kid going through cancer treatment.  They are worn for both warmth and sun protection.  Donna had dozens of them, some mailed to us by strangers, their love in every knit stitch.

I remember well Donna’s big, almond shaped eyes peering out from under the brim of whatever hat she had chosen that day.  She had the most lovely eyes.  Piercing and knowing and wise.  And so blue.  Just beautiful.  I miss those eyes staring back at me, twinkling at me.  I even miss the tears flowing from them.  Under the hat, too, was always the surprise of a bald child.

Donna's clothes.  Tulle and kimono and sailor outfits and felted wool coat with velvet collar.  Donna wore her clothing so very well.
Donna’s clothes. Tulle and kimono and sailor outfits and felted wool coat with velvet collar.

And now my tears flow.  Each of these hanging pieces have meaning to me. I have this odd knack of recalling exactly where we were when Donna wore what.  Maybe it is from all the photos we took to document a girl we knew wouldn’t always be there with us.  Regardless, I am so very grateful for the memories.

The pink tutu was a gift from Grandma.  Donna loved to wear it inside over her shorts or jeans or pajamas and dance.  She always loved to dance around the house, wherever there was music.  The kimono was a gift from a dear friend who lived in Japan.  The toys in Japan are about a thousand times cooler than the toys in the States.  So are the kimonos.

The green fairy dress brings back lovely memories.  In June 2007 Donna wore it at home when she was so sick from her first dose of chemo.  We had no idea what we were in for at that time, but there is a video of Donna coughing and wiping her dripping nose as she retrieved plastic fruit hidden all over the living room.  All the while in her green fairy costume.

The next year, on Halloween day, Donna decreed she wanted to be a Fairy Flower.  Out came the green dress.  With a few felt flowers and green leggings, POOF, Fairy Flower she was.  What a glorious day that was, Halloween 2008.  Perfection in every single way.  I was deep into my pregnancy with Mary Tyler Son.  The sun was bright, the temperature unseasonably warm, the light delicious.  And there was our little Fairy Flower, working hard to climb every stair to get her sweet treats from the kind folks charmed by her.  My Dad and sister joined us.  Halloween 2008, despite sensing it would be our last Halloween with Donna (and we were right, as Halloween 2009 was Donna’s memorial service), goes down as one of my best days ever.

There is the red floral broadcloth shirt Donna wore to her first and only school picture day.  The navy blue knit and pleated dress worn on the first day of school.  That same day the teacher pulled me aside, complimented Donna’s dress, then gently informed me pre-school was no place for dainty dresses.  Sigh.  I chuckle at the memory.

There is the sailor suit Donna wore to my Dad’s 75th birthday party.  She had had brain surgery, her third tumor resection, just ten days earlier.  Didn’t matter.  She sauntered into the party loving her frock.  There is the floral dress worn on the 4th of July when we were guests of the Mayor of Downers Grove, Illinois at their annual parade.  There is the canvas jacket that looked so hip on her.  I always wondered how Donna did hip so effortlessly.  You can’t force hip.  It just is.

Finally the teal wool coat with the velvet collar bought by our friend in Iowa from her local thrift shop.  She saw it and said it screamed DONNA to her.  It did.  It still does.  Donna wore it to the North Pole Christmas party at O’Hare Airport, a guest of United Airlines.  It was snowing that day and as Mary Tyler Dad carried Donna to the car, the snowflakes were big and delicate and sat perfectly against the blue wool and the red beret she wore to match.  She smiled, held in her Daddy’s arms, safe and warm in the snow.

So many memories, all lovely, in this closet.  So much Donna.  And still, it is time.  As we grieve our girl, our hearts flutter with the thought of a new baby. How happy that would make Donna, another brother to love.  She knows. She always did.

We love you, girl, still and always.  We’ll meet you there.

Do you enjoy the occasional dose of perspective you get from reading my words?  If so, subscribe! 

Type your email address in the box and click the “create subscription” button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.